Created by Peter S. Fischer, William Link and Richard Levinson — the latter two were also the creators of Columbo — this show was originally going to star Jean Stapleton, who turned it down. Angela Lansbury, who had played Ms. Marple in several movies, was the perfect choice to play Jessica MacGill Fletcher, a woman from a small coastal New England town who goes on to become a famous author and mystery solver, if not a serial killer with all of the people who die around her.
If you’re wondering, where is Cabot Cove? It’s Mendocino, CA and Noyo Harbor in Fort Bragg, CA.
I’m obsessed by this show. The fact that it has so many murders around one woman, the fact that all kinds of exploitation actors show up in it and the fact that so many white-haired dudes are vying to pound it out with Jessica. I watch the Murder, She Wrote Pluto and Roku channels constantly, jumping into episodes and knowing exactly where they are, because I’ve watched them so often. My wife and I own the gigantic early DVD box sets, even the TV movies.
Why should I keep this all to myself? I should share my Jessica Fletcher mania with you.

Pilot episode: The Murder of Sherlock Holmes (September 30, 1984)
Tonight on Murder, She Wrote…
In the episode that kicks off the entire show, Jessica Fletcher travels to New York City to celebrate the release of her debut novel — just in time for someone to get killed at a costume party.
Who’s in it, outside of Angela Lansbury and were they in any exploitation movies?
Peter Brill is played by Bert Convy, who, in addition to being in two episodes of Murder, She Wrote, also shows up in Jennifer and A Bucket of Blood.
Herb Edelman appears and would later be NYPD Lieutenant Artie Gelber, a role he’d play seven times on the show. He also is in the Hong Kong action film Wheels On Meals.
As Rocky Horror tells us, Anne Francis stars in Forbidden Planet. She was also in the supernatural TV movie Haunts of the Very Rich and three episodes of this show, starting with this episode as Louise McCallum.
Michael Horton makes his first Murder, She Wrote appearance as one of my most hated characters. Grady Fletcher. He’d be on the show twelve times, always screwing things up and needing his aunt Jessica to come in and save him. Since the show, he’s appeared in several Star Trek shows and films.
Dennis Patrick, who played Dexter Baxendale in this episode, has appeared in several roles on Dark Shadows and played rich man Bill Compton in the early Cannon movie Joe. He’s also appeared in Nightmare Honeymoon, The Time Travelers and many other TV roles.
The doctor in this episode was played by Raymond St. Jacques, a street preacher in They Live, Claude in the John Russo adaptation Voodoo Dawn, opposite Bronson in The Evil That Men Do and also shows up in Cotton Comes to Harlem.
This episode, as you can tell, is packed with stars. Ned Beatty may be the biggest, appearing as Chief Roy Gunderson. He has 163 roles in his career, most of them in major Hollywood productions. Still, we can count 21st Century’s Captain America, Repossessed, Purple People Eater, The Unholy, Rolling Vengeance and Exorcist II: The Heretic as exploitation in my book.
Arthur Hill, who plays Preston Giles, Jessica’s first publisher, in two episodes of this series, also narrates Something Wicked This Way Comes, is the vice president in Murder In Space and appears in Revenge of the Stepford Wives, Futureworld and The Andromeda Strain.
Brian Keith was an actor with 169 roles, including Uncle Ben in the 90s Spider-Man cartoon, Papa in Sharky’s Machine, Dr. Dubov in Meteor and the Dad in The Parent Trap.
Paddi Edwards, Lois Hoey was a secretary in Halloween III! Sure, she’s Flotsam and Jetsam in the Disney cartoons, but this is the role I’m happy for.
The radio show host, Danny Welles, is Luigi from the TV show Super Mario Supershow!
Marvin is played by Stanley Brock, Weird Al’s uncle in UHF.
In the minor roles — there are no minor roles! — we have Johnny Venokur (Savage Streets, Evil Laugh) as a tough, Andy Garcia (!) as his co-tough, Mama Fratelli herself Anne Ramsey as a bag lady, Paula Victor (The Entity), Billie Hayes (Witchiepoo!), Beau Star (Sheriff Meeker from Halloween 4 and 5) as a cop, KTLA anchor Larry McCormick and Sallee Young (Home Sweet Home, Demented and Pandemonium).
What happens?
Jessica Fletcher is a widower and schoolteacher from Cabot Cova, Maine—yes, I know we all know this, but it’s the first episode—whose hobby is writing mysteries. Her excoriable nephew Grady sends one of those stories to publisher Preston Giles, who buys it. Now Jessica has to come to New York City and hates every second. Giles begs for her to stay on for his costume party.
She meets composer Peter Brill, Grady’s boss, Captain Caleb McCallum, his wife Louise and the rich Ashley Vickers. Up until the murder- it’s right there in the title- everything is fun, and people are super into Jessica dressing like Cinderlla’s fairy godmother until Dexter Baxendale, a detective, is caught looking around. And oh yeah, Caleb is getting killed, dressed as Sherlock Holmes, to explain that this episode’s title wasn’t lying. Shot in the head, left floating face down in a pool, but then it’s discovered that Caleb is alive, and that’s Baxendale’s body.
Jessica is shocked that, of all people, Grady gets arrested for the murder. Stick around for 12 seasons and see how surprised you will be that Grady gets into some shenanigans. Jessica must solve the case and potentially fall in love with Giles. Except that, well…
Who did it?
Giles is the killer, as he used to work with the detective, and his past crimes would be revealed to him. It looks like Jessica has to get a new publisher.
Who made it?
Corey Allan directed, and he is a veteran of TV shows and an actor who was in Rebel Without a Cause. Fischer, Levinson and Link, who created the show, wrote the story, which Fischer turned into a script.
Mario Di Leo, the cinematographer on The Evil and a still photographer for the berserk Italian movie Top Line, shot this. That last fact is blowing my mind.
Some facts…
Jessica is introduced just like Miss Marple in The Mirror Crack’d, a movie adaptation starring Lansbury. She also types her books on a 1940s Royal typewriter, the same one that Ellery Queen used on the series from the same producers.
How many people live in Cabot Cove? 3,560. Well, for now. By the end of the series, many of them are dead.
Does Jessica get some?
This is a significant point of debate for me with every episode of Murder, She Wrote. Jessica is supposedly in her early 50s, just like me, so she’s still a woman with wants and needs. It seems like many older gentlemen in this show would love to dig up some sand crabs with our heroine, and I say we should champion this.
Preston Giles is one of the few of her would-be men who kisses her full on the lips. Seeing how he comes back to woo her again in season 7, I will say that he could not get enough once he had a taste of her New England baking. So yes, I will say that they at least engaged in heavy petting and perhaps Jessica rubbed up against him. She’s a lady, however, and I don’t think she went into the pants or gave him an Old Fashioned at this early stage of their relationship.
But this dialogue!
Preston Giles: I’m so sorry. I should have told you. For tonight’s party, we’re coming dressed as our favorite fictional character. I know, I know. You haven’t got a thing to wear.
Jessica Fletcher: Well, I could always come as Lady Godiva.
This is cut footage of Jessica directly after they spoke…
Does Jessica dress up and act stupid?
Yes and no. She does wear an outfit, but it’s for a costume party. This gets her off the hook, but as the show continues, look for Jessica to put on costumes and act drunk more than the Harts.
Was it any good?
There’s some math to do here. Any episode with Grady in it can’t be a perfect ten, as his presence angers me to madness. However, this has a solid mystery, even if it’s cribbed from Agatha Christie’s “The Affair At The Victory Ball.” It’s also a two-parter with a pretty decent plot that sets up all the show’s beats. So I’d say yes. No secret spinoff or Jessica is being wasted, things that ruin later episodes.
Give me a reasonable quote:
“You know, back in Cabot Cove, the only thing we have with claws are lobsters, and we eat ’em.”
Got a TV Guide ad?
CBS really wanted this to be a success because there’s a double-page ad!

What’s next?
In “Deadly Lady,” a visitor who has stopped at Jessica’s house turns up dead, swept away in a hurricane before Jessica even meets him. Get ready to meet Captain Ethan Cragg and Sheriff Amos Tupper, two lawmen I think both slept with Jessica. At the same time? Let’s discuss.





You must be logged in to post a comment.