Jessica’s British cousin, Emma MacGill (Angela Lansbury!), is charged with an old flame’s murder.

Season 4, Episode 5: It Runs In the Family (November 1, 1987)
You see, most folks know Angela Lansbury as Jessica Fletcher, the Cabot Cove death-magnet who publishes paperbacks and stumbles over more corpses than the entire Corleone family. But the real heads know that the producers occasionally let Lansbury completely cut loose and play her own identical British cousin, Emma McGill. When Emma’s on the screen, the show stops being a cozy New England procedural and transforms into a full-blown British melodrama. We’re talking gothic manor houses, inheritance disputes and family members who hate each other.
Who’s in it, outside of Angela Lansbury?
- Richard Johnson (Lord Geoffrey Constable): The doomed love interest in a smoking jacket here, but genre fans worship him as the desperate Dr. Menard from Lucio Fulci’s legendary, eye-gouging, shark-fighting gore-fest Zombie, as well as Sergio Martino’s The Case of the Scorpion’s Tail.
- Carolyn Seymour (Pauline Constable): The insecure, overcompensating villainess of the manor, but genre fans know her as the resilient Abby Grant from the bleak, post-apocalyptic BBC cult series Survivors and a beautifully icy Romulan Commander in Star Trek: The Next Generation.
- Anthony Newley (Insp. Frost): The baffled local inspector, but genre fans know him as the avant-garde mastermind who directed, scored and starred in the unhinged, deeply surrealist 1969 psychedelic comedy-drama Can Heironymus Merkin Ever Forget Mercy Humppe and Find True Happiness?
- Ian Abercrombie (Dr. Blandings): The stuffy aristocratic physician, but you know him as the robed, Necronomicon-guarding Wise Man from Sam Raimi’s medieval-slapstick horror masterpiece Army of Darkness.
- Mark Lindsay Chapman (Johnny Constable): The unpleasant nephew who sneaks poisoned chocolates, but he was also the mutated, maniacal arch-nemesis Dr. Anton Arcane from the USA Network’s beloved ’90s Swamp Thing TV series.
- Jane Leeves (Gwen Petrie): The bit-part housemaid way before her Frasier fame, but she was also one of the high-kicking dancers in the legendary “Every Sperm is Sacred” musical extravaganza from Monty Python’s The Meaning of Life.
- Christopher Hewett (Humphrey Defoe): The family lawyer looking over the will, but genre fans know him way before his Mr. Belvedere sitcom days as the flamboyant, dress-wearing theatrical assistant Roger De Bris in Mel Brooks’s comedy classic The Producers.
- John Standing (Arthur Constable): The only sane member of the family heritage, but genre fans know him from Peter Greenaway’s visually obsessive arthouse drama The Belly of an Architect and the gritty, star-studded WWII thriller The Eagle Has Landed.
- John David Bland (Derek Constable): The spoiled brat kid who gets shot in the arm for a frame-up, but genre fans know him as the ultimate, leather-jacket-wearing ’90s television hunk from the syndicated, high-camp action explosion Acapulco H.E.A.T.
- Rosemary Murphy (Sybil Constable): The legendary, icy matriarch who drives her daughter-in-law to commit double homicide just by turning up her nose. She played Sara Delano Roosevelt in Eleanor and Franklin, but you may have also seen her in To Kill a Mockingbird and A Case of Rape.
- Lester Fletcher (Rev. Twilley): The pious man of God trying to keep the peace. He was also the dramatic, silk-scarf-wearing elite art critic from the high-camp, neon-soaked ’80s detective classic Remington Steele.
- Pamela Kosh (Mrs. Dexter-Hundley): The ultimate disapproving upper-crust aristocrat, but genre fans know her as the deeply eccentric, bird-brained substitute teacher Miss Davis who tried to bring British discipline to Bayside High in Saved by the Bell.
- Peter Browne (Butler): The stiff-lipped servant carrying the poisoned herring on a silver platter. He also has a career in stunt-adjacent, blink-and-you-miss-him background work across high-concept ’80s action cheese like Knight Rider and Airwolf.
- Peter Ashton (Burt): The local working-class bloke hanging around the edges of the estate. He was a certified background legend of British television, having spent years playing various soldiers, sailors and sketchy dockworkers in everything from Doctor Who to The Twilight Zone.
- D.J. Sullivan (Pru): The gossiping village local keeping tabs on the manor house. You may recognize her as Mrs. Williams from the Killer Tomatoes movies.
What happens?
We open at a lavish family dinner at Blackraven Manor. The atmosphere is so thick with snobbery you could cut it with a silver butter knife. Sybil and Pauline are treating Emma like she’s a stray dog that wandered into the dining room. They think she’s a gold digger after Geoffrey’s fortune.
But Geoffrey? He’s glowing. The doctor said he was a goner, but The Power of Love is real, folks. Emma gets up, winks at the piano player, and launches into a lively rendition of “Spoon With Me” (a total actor allusion to Lansbury’s 1946 flick Till the Clouds Roll By). Geoffrey is captivated. Pauline looks like she swallowed a lemon.
Later, in the library, Geoffrey pours his heart out to Emma, mentioning his old friends Oliver and Kitty Trumbull. He tells her he’s rewriting his will.
The next afternoon, the family gathers for high tea and snacks. Geoffrey enjoys his favorite treat: pickled herring. Ten minutes later, he’s clutching his throat and collapsing onto the Persian rug. The local inspector arrives, and because the family points their manicured fingers right at Emma, she becomes the prime suspect. But Emma isn’t Jessica Fletcher’s cousin for nothing.
Emma starts snooping. She realizes something fishy. Geoffrey’s ninety-year-old father died a month ago. Everyone blamed old age, but Emma realizes both men were poisoned. Meanwhile, family drama boils over. Derek demands money from his dad for a ski trip. Arthur, stepping up as the new Viscount, finally grows a backbone.
To throw the cops off the scent, Pauline does the unthinkable: she shoots her own son, Derek, in the arm, trying to frame Johnny (who was already a suspect because he sneaked grandfather those poisoned chocolates). But Emma pieces it all together. The snobbery, the timing, the inheritance. She gathers everyone in the grand drawing room for the classic Fletcher-style reveal.
Emma lays it out: Pauline killed the old Viscount, then killed Geoffrey, all so Arthur would inherit the title immediately, making Pauline the new Viscountess Blackraven. Then, she produces the evidence, as she’s found the poison trace in Pauline’s vanity.
Pauline collapses into a sobbing, pathetic heap on the floor as Sybil realizes that her snobbery literally killed her father and her brother.
Who made it?
Another episode by TV vet Walter Grauman, written by series creator Peter S. Fischer.
Does Jessica dress up and act stupid? Does she get some?
Yes. A whole episode of Emma!
Was it any good?
Yes! A classic episode even without J.B.
Any trivia?
Jessica Fletcher never appears in person. This is the only time in the entire series where this happens.
Richard Johnson revealed that while he was on set getting poisoned by pickled herring for this episode, it was his long-time partner-in-crime, Angela Lansbury, who staged a full-blown career intervention. The two of them went way back. They’d shared the screen two decades earlier in Terence Young’s costume-comedy romp The Amorous Adventures of Moll Flanders. By the time 1987 rolled around, Johnson had largely stepped away from the camera to play the suit, running his own outfit called United British Artists. He was busy producing heavy-hitting arthouse fare like Harold Pinter’s Turtle Diary, Nicolas Roeg’s desert-island drama Castaway, and the utterly devastating Jack Clayton flick The Lonely Passion of Judith Hearne. But Lansbury wasn’t having any of it. She looked her old pal dead in the eye and laid down the law, telling him: “Anybody can be a producer, Richard. You actually have talent as an actor, and you are completely wasting it!” Do you think she saw Island of the Fishmen?
Give me a reasonable quote:
Emma: “Well, Jessica always said mystery has a way of finding our family. I suppose it really does run in the blood.”
What’s next?
The night deputy, who has been paying attention to various Cabot Cove ladies, needs Jessica’s help when he becomes the prime suspect in his wife’s murder.
You must be logged in to post a comment.