DAY 5. Teenagers!
Is this a teen movie? It’s in Teen Movie Hell, so good enough.
Father Michael McClaren (Sam Bottoms) is what we call a cool priest. Sure, he teaches college in Florida, but he plays basketball, rides a motorcycle and is popular with the kids. The church wants him to debate former priest C.A. Thomas (Robert Lansing, 4D Man, Island Claws, Scalpel), who has written a novel claiming that man created God, on the Dick Cavett Show. Yes, this is a teen sex comedy — well, it’s closer to a relationship drama, but the poster wants you to think it’s a sex comedy — in which Dick Cavett shows up.
This would all be normal except for two things.
One, it’s not that crazy that a girl named September Lane (Renee Coleman) falls in love with Father Michael. You may know her as left fielder Alice Gaspers from A League of Their Own and the evil leaper Alia on Quantum Leap. Or perhaps as the kidnap victim John Candy is trying to save in Who’s Harry Crumb? Man, her IMDb is awesome, because it contains this: “In 1995, Coleman left the film business and returned to school, where she earned her Mythological Studies doctorate (with an emphasis on Depth Psychology) at Pacifica Graduate Institute in 2002. She currently lives with her husband and their four children in Santa Clarita, California, where she works in a private practice as a certified DreamTender.”
The second thing that makes this strange is that, every once in a while, this movie goes back to caveman times, complete with naked women. That’s why this was originally titled Return to Eden. However, those parts really have next to nothing to do with the rest of the movie.
When Thomas and Father Michael do finally debate with Dick Cavett, Thomas wins, saying that every man has to find his own God. So Michael goes off to look up September, and they turn into naked cave people. The end. Really, that’s how it ends.
Things happen in this movie that make no sense, even more than you’d expect, like a priest randomly being into aerobics, September falling for the holy man, and him saying he loves her. Why? She’s moody and constantly argues with him. I mean, that’s almost every woman I’ve dated, so I think I answered my own question.
This was the first role for Sherrie Rose, who would go on to be in movies like Killer Crocodile, Cy Warrior, American Rickshaw and Guns & Lipstick (which has a totally amazing cast of Sally Kellerman, Jorge Rivero, Wings Hauser, James Hong, Sonny Landham, Joe Estvez, Robert Forster, Cassie Yates and girls-only adult star Felicia). Plus, Page Hannah appears, and she’d go on to be a victim of the oil slick in Creepshow 2.
After School was directed by William Olsen, who also made Rockin’ Road Trip, Getting It On, Southern Belles and Mastering the Theremin. This had four writers: Hugh Parks (the director of Shakma!), Joe Tankersley, John Lind and Rod McBrien, who wrote the music for the movie Club Fed, which I must have cast, as it stars Burt Young, Judy Landers, Sherman Hemsley, Karen Black, Mary Woronov, Lyle Alzado, Wally George, Dee “Queen Kong/Matilda the Hun” Booher, Lance “Proctor” Kinsey and Debbie Lee Carrington.
I was not ready for this movie.
You can watch this on Tubi.