A temporary blackout at a recording studio leaves Jessica in the dark when the wealthy, soon-to-be-owner is stabbed to death.

Season 3, Episode 22: Murder, She Spoke (May 10, 1987)
Jessica has been booked in a studio to record her mystery books as part of a series for the blind. Mid-recording, a blackout hits the studio, and when the lights come back on, someone discovers Randy Whitman, the owner-to-be, dying of a stab wound to the back.
Who’s in it, outside of Angela Lansbury?
William Atherton (Greg Dalton): The undisputed king of the “guy you love to hate.” Before he was getting his house covered in marshmallows in Ghostbusters, he was starring in the 1974 cult classic The Sugarland Express. Seriously, his IMDb is filled with roles that should just say “jerk.”
G.W. Bailey (Lt. Oswald Faraday): Long before he was the bumbling Captain Harris in Police Academy, Bailey was dodging the undead in Tom McLoughlin’s moody 1982 cult horror One Dark Night.
Michael Callan (Carl Anglin): A veteran of the screen who took a dip into the “Nature Gone Wild” subgenre with the 1977 giant-cat-on-the-loose flick The Uncanny, and appeared in the giallo-influenced TV thriller The Killer on Board.
Michael Cole (Earl Tuchman): Best known as Pete from The Mod Squad, but he earned his horror stripes playing the adult Henry Bowers in the original 1990 miniseries adaptation of Stephen King’s It.
Charlie Daniels (Stoney Carmichael): The man who told us the Devil went down to Georgia. While primarily a country legend, his presence here adds that grit necessary for a Southern-fried thriller.
Jonna Lee (Sally Ann Carmichael): A 1980s mainstay who faced off against a supernatural force in the 1984 film Making the Grade.
Fredric Lehne (Al Parker): You recognize him as the “Yellow-Eyed Demon” (Azazel) from Supernatural. He’s a genre veteran who also appeared in Night Game, a slasher set at a baseball stadium.
Wendy Phillips (Nancy Dalton): She survived the 1988 TV movie The People Across the Lake, which is a textbook “suburban nightmare” thriller.
Constance Towers (Margaret Witworth): A genuine icon of cult cinema. She starred in Samuel Fuller’s insane 1963 masterpiece Shock Corridor and the 1964 neo-noir The Naked Kiss. If you haven’t seen them, fix your life.
Patrick Wayne (Randy Witworth): The son of The Duke himself. He led the charge against Ray Harryhausen monsters in the 1977 fantasy-adventure cult classic Sinbad and the Eye of the Tiger.
Mark Neely (Sergeant): A familiar face from The Young and the Restless, Neely also did time in the 1981 slasher Graduation Day.
Trish Garland (Secretary): Mostly known for her stage work, but she popped up in the psychological thriller The 4th Floor.
Austin Kelly (Cabbie): A reliable character actor who appeared in the gritty 1970s crime-cult classic Across 110th Street.
What happens?
If you thought the most dangerous thing in a recording studio was a high-pitched feedback loop or a diva’s rider, you clearly haven’t spent enough time in Cabot Cove’s extended universe.
In this week’s episode, our favorite mystery writer is recording her books for the blind. Naturally, because Jessica can’t even go to the grocery store without someone checking out permanently, a blackout hits the studio. When the lights flicker back on, Randy Whitman—the studio’s owner-to-be and a man with all the charm of a paper cut—is found with a knife in his back.
Enter Lt. Faraday, played by G.W. Bailey, who has apparently decided that since he can’t stop Mahoney and Tackleberry, he’ll spend his time being a condescending misogynist to a world-famous novelist. Faraday immediately pivots his detective skills toward Greg Dalton, the blind producer.
Why Greg? Because Faraday’s logic is airtight: Greg can move in the dark, he was near the switch, and he’s the suspicious type. Meanwhile, Jessica finds a bottle of expensive purple nail polish at the scene. That leads her to:
- Suspect A: Cindy, the runaway niece of country star Stoney Carmichael, wears purple polish, but it’s the cheap stuff.
- Suspect B: The victim’s widow, who seems about as sad as someone who just won the lottery, wears the expensive brand.
- The Reality: The nail polish is a Total Red Herring. It has absolutely nothing to do with the murder, but it gives Jessica something to do while Faraday is busy being useless.
Things get messy when Jessica catches Nancy Dalton (Greg’s wife) trying to hide a set of matching silverware in the dryer. Pro tip: if your husband is a murder suspect, don’t try to tumble-dry the evidence. Jessica has to gently remind her that “Obstruction of Justice” isn’t a great look for the fall season.
The lightbulb — literally, see the trivia — finally goes off for J.B. when Faraday calls her and mistakes her recorded voice for her actual voice. Suddenly, the blackout rehearsals and the constant technical difficulties during Stoney’s recording sessions make sense.
Who did it?
Al Parker. He flipped a master switch on his keyboard to cause the blackouts, using them as dress rehearsals to frame Greg (who was conveniently distracted by his meds at the time).
How did Al pull off the ultimate alibi? The old Recorded Audio Trick. He made it look like Randy was calling him on the phone, but Al was actually just listening to a recording of Randy’s voice. This kept Randy pinned in one spot for the stabbing while making Al look like he was elsewhere, chatting away with the soon-to-be corpse.
Al tries to play it cool, claiming the evidence is circumstantial, which is a classic move for a guy who just got outsmarted by a woman in a smart blazer. It isn’t until Faraday finds the actual alibi tape (thanks to a heavy nudge from Jessica) that Al finally folds.
Faraday ends the episode by graciously admitting he’ll never undervalue female intuition again. Jessica likely responded with a polite smile, while internally calculating exactly how many ways she could have disposed of his body without leaving a trace.
Be nice to Jessica Fletcher. She has a very intimate relationship with death.
Who made it?
This was directed by Jessica’s real-life son, Anthony Pullen Shaw and written by Si Rose, who created Sigmund and the Sea Monster and Dr. Shrinker.
Does Jessica dress up and act stupid? Does she get some?
No. I’m wondering if I’ll ever see that again. Maybe in season 4? This is the last episode of season 3.
Was it any good?
Yes!
Any trivia?
The moment that Jessica figures out who the murderer is, a light bulb comes on above her head.

Screenshot
Give me a reasonable quote:
Lt. Faraday: Oh, I think writing is a real good hobby for a woman. You can cook up some supper. You can chat on the phone. And then pop over to the old typewriter now and then for a few minutes.
Jessica Fletcher: Yes. When I’m not too busy beating laundry against the rocks in the river.
What’s next?
The first episode of season 4! Jessica jaunts to Paris at the behest of an old friend whose fashion boutique is in financial trouble. When a local loan shark is murdered, she must dig deep to find the truth.




You must be logged in to post a comment.