When a prisoner is released from jail after serving 20 years, he returns to Cabot Cove to prove he was wrongly convicted.

Season 4, Episode 2: When Thieves Fall Out (September 27, 1987)

Twenty years is a long time to stew in a cage. It’s long enough for a town like Cabot Cove to turn a pack of local jocks into pillars of the community and long enough for a man like Andrew Durbin to decide it’s time he got his life back.

Who’s in it, outside of Angela Lansbury?

Tom Bosley (Sheriff Amos Tupper): Before he was dealing with Jessica’s meddling, he was America’s dad, Howard Cunningham, on Happy Days. Cult fans know him as the voice of The World of David the Gnome.

John Glover (Andrew Durbin): An absolute legend of the unsettling character actor pantheon. He’s best known as Lionel Luthor on Smallville and the billionaire Daniel Clamp in Gremlins 2: The New Batch. He’s also been in In the Mouth of Madness and was the voice of the Riddler in the 90s Batman: The Animated Series.

Michael Lembeck (Arnie Wakeman): Known for playing Max Horvath on One Day at a Time, Lembeck eventually moved behind the lens to direct The Santa Clause sequels.

Kenneth McMillan (Coach Kevin Cauldwell): You know him. You fear him. He’s the Baron Vladimir Harkonnen from David Lynch’s Dune (the one with the boils and the floating). He also played the grumpy Captain in The Taking of Pelham One Two Three and the neighbor in Cat’s Eye.

Caitlin O’Heaney (Tara Sillman): The ultimate Final Girl credential here: she was the lead, Amy, in the 1981 slasher classic He Knows You’re Alone (which featured a young Tom Hanks). She also starred in the short-lived but beloved adventure series Tales of the Gold Monkey.

John Bennett Perry (Judge Perry Sillman): Yes, he’s Matthew Perry’s dad. He’s been in everything from Independence Day to George of the Jungle.

Dack Rambo (Bill Hampton): Best known as Jack Ewing on Dallas. He had that perfectly coiffed 80s hair that seemed built for primetime soaps, but he also appeared in the cult horror-thriller Nightmare Honeymoon.

Shelley Smith (Alison Hampton): A former supermodel turned actress who was a staple of the game show circuit. She had a lead role in the series The Associates and appeared in the TV horror flick The Memory of Eva Ryker.

Mark Voland (Dan Pulling): A reliable TV face seen in The Love Boat and Matlock. He specializes in playing the “guy who might be the killer but is probably just a jerk.”

Charles Summers (Doc Mathews): A veteran of TV, popping up in Falcon Crest and various soaps.

Dick Durock (Man Stopping Fight): Keep your eyes peeled for the man breaking up the scuffle. Durock is the Swamp Thing. He played the mossy hero in both the 1982 Wes Craven film and the 1989 sequel, as well as the TV series. He’s a stunt legend who has been punched by every leading man in Hollywood.

What happens?

Durbin arrives in Maine with a chip on his shoulder the size of a lighthouse. Two decades ago, he was a hitchhiker who survived a car crash that killed a wealthy businessman. While Durbin ran for help, someone else showed up and finished the job, bashing the businessman’s head in with a rock and making off with $100,000 in bearer bonds. Durbin took the fall, largely because he was a long-haired anti-war protester in a town that didn’t like his kind.

He’s back because he finally recognized the face of the kid driving that other car: Bill Hampton, now a successful car dealer. Durbin starts a psychological war, hovering around Hampton like a ghost, eventually setting a trap by leaving his car at the dealership. Jessica, of course, gets pulled in when Hampton’s wife starts worrying about her husband’s fraying nerves. But before J.B. can mediate, Bill turns up dead with a bullet in his head and a suicide note blaming Durbin’s harassment.

Jessica notices the “suicide” was a right-handed shot to a left-handed man. The killer didn’t just want Bill dead; they wanted to frame Durbin again. But this isn’t your standard “Aunt Jess catches a greedy nephew” episode. It’s a deep dive into the rot beneath the surface of small-town nostalgia.

We get a classic subplot with Arnie Wakeman, a former athlete in a wheelchair, suing Hampton. In a moment of pure Jessica sleuthing, she notices scuff marks on a waxed floor and realizes Arnie is really unhurt. Speaking of athletes, this one centers on the state-champion football team of twenty years ago. These men are the town’s heroes, and their leader was Coach Cauldwell.

Who did it?

The reveal is a gut-punch. Coach Cauldwell wasn’t just a mentor; he was the one who saw the accident, saw the money and chose greed over the lives of his boys. When he realized the businessman was still alive, he used a rock to protect his future. Twenty years later, when Bill Hampton got cold feet about Durbin’s return, the Coach killed him, too. He viewed Bill like a son, but apparently, $100k and a reputation are worth more than family.

This is one of the rare downers on the show. Usually, when the handcuffs click, Jessica shares a laugh with Amos or Seth over a bowl of chowder. Not here. Jessica is genuinely wounded. She lost a friend in the Coach and discovered that her beloved neighbors were complicit in hiding a crime for two decades. When she confronts Durbin at the end, she displays that libertine scold energy—it almost feels like she’s actually annoyed at him for bringing the truth to light because of the collateral damage to her social circle.

Just look at this dialogue:

Jessica: I can’t help but think that justice could have been served in a better way.

Durbin: Oh? Well, you give it some thought, Mrs. Fletcher, and when you figure out what could have been, you let me know.

Who made it?

This was directed by Seymour Robbie and written by Arthur Weingarten. Speaking of Tales of the Golden Monkey, he wrote episodes of the other Indiana Jones cash-in TV series of the 1982-83 season, Bring ‘Em Back Alive.

Does Jessica dress up and act stupid? Does she get some?

No, this is a serious episode.

Was it any good?

Yes! I love learning that Cabot Cove isn’t always such a nice place to live.

Any trivia?

This episode’s title is from James William Emery Townsend, who said, “When thieves fall out, honest men get their dues. But when honest men fall out, lawyers get their fees.”

We learn in this episode that the population of Cabot Cove is 3,560. I expect it will be lower by the end of the series.

Give me a reasonable quote:

Andrew Durbin: I came to say good-bye and to thank you.

Jessica Fletcher: I’d rather you didn’t.

Andrew Durbin: But I was telling you the truth, and I did spend 20 years in prison unjustly.

Jessica Fletcher: Yes. And I’m sorry. But you knew when you came here what would happen.

Andrew Durbin: I wasn’t sure, but I did warn you I was after justice.

What’s next?

Jessica goes to Quebec to testify at the trial of a friend who is accused of killing his wife and burning his house.

Jessica jaunts to Paris at the behest of an old friend whose fashion boutique is in financial trouble. When a local loan shark is murdered, Jessica must dig deep to find the truth.

Season 4, Episode 1: A Fashionable Way to Die (September 20, 1987)

Jessica flies to France to attend a big fashion show of one of her old friends. Will someone die? Have you ever watched this show?

Who’s in it, outside of Angela Lansbury?

Lee Bergere (Maxim Soury): A veteran character actor best known for extensive television work across the 1960s–80s, including frequent appearances in suspense and crime dramas.  Best known to science fiction fans for playing Abraham Lincoln in the Star Trek: The Original Series episode “The Savage Curtain.” He’s also in the movies Time Trackers and played Joseph Anders on Dynasty.

Bill Beyers (Peter Appleyard): Primarily a working television performer who was in Tuff Turf.

Danielle Brisebois (Kim Bechet): Famous as a child star playing Stephanie Mills on All in the Family and Archie Bunker’s Place, and Molly in the original Broadway cast of Annie. She later became a successful songwriter (co-writing “Unwritten” for Natasha Bedingfield).

Randi Brooks (Lu Watters): Appeared in the cult sci-fi comedy The Man with Two Brains and the 80s action-horror Terror on Highway 91, as well as TerrorVision and Hamburger: The Motion Picture.

Taina Elg (Claudia Soury): A Golden Age film actress with a strong background in stage and screen, but she was also in Hercules In New York.

Juliet Prowse (Valerie Bechet): A celebrated dancer and performer known for musical films and television variety work. She’s in Who Killed Teddy Bear.

Barbara Rush (Eva Taylor): Known for Magnificent Obsession, The Young Philadelphians and her long-running role on 7th Heaven. Remembered for science fiction and suspense films such as It Came from Outer Space.

Fritz Weaver (Paris Inspector Hugues Panassié): A distinguished stage and screen actor strongly associated with high-profile genre television. Known for standout roles in psychological thrillers and science-fiction/horror classics like Creepshow, Demon Seed and episodes of The Twilight Zone.

Karen Hensel (Marie): A steady television character actress with a long career of guest roles across soap operas, crime dramas and procedural series, including the movies Psycho 3 and Caged Fear.

Michel Voletti (Officer Luter): Appears frequently in European film and television productions, often in supporting roles as law enforcement or authority figures.

Bonnie Ebsen (Yvette): Daughter of Buddy Ebsen; she appeared in several 80s hits like The Fall Guy and Hunter. She’s also in Black Magic Woman, which stars Apollonia and Mark Hamill.

Louise Dorsey (Dede): She’s the daughter of legendary crooner Engelbert Humperdinck and was the voice of Jetta on Jem.

Jean-Paul Vignon (Emcee): A character actor frequently cast in sophisticated or stylized supporting roles, often in European-influenced productions and genre-adjacent television.

Jules Hart (Margo): Appearing under the name Julie Silliman, she’s most often associated with television guest roles and supporting appearances in dramatic and thriller-oriented episodes.

Smaller roles include Alain Saint-Alix as a bellman, Louis Plante as Albert (as Louis R. Plante), Larry Carr, Paul LeClair and Ken Clayton as fashion show spectators, Conrad Hurtt as a cop and Nico Stevens as a reporter.

What happens?

Jessica does what she does best: flies to France, walks into an absolutely glitter-soaked mess and immediately becomes the only competent investigator in a 10-mile radius of haute couture after someone dies.

Her old friend Eva Taylor is on the verge of a career breakthrough, finally ready to shine at a major fashion show, if only she hadn’t signed her soul away in a contract with Maxim Soury, a man who treats financial backing like organized extortion but with better tailoring. He offers her funding and a loan extension in exchange for 50% of her brand, which is not a good deal, but she has to accept it.

Meanwhile, the supporting cast is busy turning Paris into a soap opera:

• Valerie Bechet, nightclub chanteuse and Maxim’s discarded mistress, is singing heartbreak ballads professionally while living one bad mood away from homicide. 
• Lu Watters, inexplicably broke fashion superstar, is bleeding money thanks to Maxim’s blackmail operation involving some very inconvenient photographs from her past. 
• Officer Panassie is busy being confidently wrong about literally everything, including why Jessica wants to be anywhere near him.

Then Maxim turns up dead.

Naturally, the glitter immediately curdles into suspicion; everyone has a motive, and Eva is one bad headline away from becoming the designated scapegoat. J.B., meanwhile, is forced to untangle a web of blackmail, jealousy, and fashion-industry moral rot while politely tolerating French bureaucracy and men who think she’s there for romance instead of forensic reasoning.

Who did it?

The killer turns out to be Valerie Bechet.

Maxim’s habit of discarding women like seasonal collections finally catches up to him when he pushes things too far, this time involving Valerie’s daughter, Kim. The realization that Maxim has set his sights on the next generation is the final straw. Valerie, already simmering with resentment over being tossed aside and replaced, decides the show must go on permanently without its producer.

One dramatic confrontation later, Maxim is dead, Valerie’s nightclub act takes on a whole new level of tragic irony, and Jessica is left doing what she always does: solving a murder while everyone else processes the emotional wreckage of dating financially predatory villains in couture.

Eva is cleared, the fashion show limps forward in scandalous glory, and France once again learns the hard way that if Jessica Fletcher shows up, someone in your social circle is statistically going to go to Heaven. Or Hell. Or whatever.

Who made it?

This was directed by TV veteran Nick Havinga and written by Donald Ross, the man who wrote Hamburger: The Motion Picture.

Does Jessica dress up and act stupid? Does she get some?

Dudes in France love some le belle-âge J.B. But as far as we know, no hanky panky.

Was it any good?

Yes!

Any trivia?

While the episode is busy serving murder, fashion and scandal, it’s also quietly swinging with some deep-cut jazz references:

• Valerie and Kim Bechet tip their hats to Sidney Bechet, the legendary New Orleans clarinetist and soprano sax player who brought his sound to Europe as early as 1919—and later spent much of his final decade living it up in France. 
• Inspector Hugues Panassié is named after Hugues Panassié, a major French jazz critic and author who championed traditional jazz and wrote books such as The Real Jazz. 
• Officer Luter is a nod to Claude Luter, the Parisian bandleader who frequently collaborated with Bechet during his French years. 
• Eva Taylor shares her name with Eva Taylor, a 1920s vocalist who recorded extensively with her husband, bandleader and songwriter Clarence Williams. 
• And then there’s Lu Watters—borrowed from Lu Watters, a (male) trumpeter who helped spark a New Orleans-style revival scene in San Francisco back in 1940.

In the unmistakably Paris-set exterior shots, it’s not actually Angela Lansbury you’re seeing up close. A stand-in of similar build steps in, dressed identically but with slightly darker hair, cut shorter in the back. The camera then goes into full “don’t look too closely” mode, keeping her at a distance, filming from behind, or, conveniently, staging cars in the foreground. When she arrives at Le Jules Verne, the illusion gets especially cheeky: just as she turns toward the camera, another character’s hat swoops in to block her face.

Give me a reasonable quote:

Paris Inspector Hugues Panassié: The color is immaterial. Place her in custody. Panassie has done it again, huh?

Jessica Fletcher: Yes, Inspector, I think you have.

Paris Inspector Hugues Panassié: Merci, madam.

Jessica Fletcher: I think you’ve once again arrested the wrong woman.

What’s next?

When a prisoner is released from jail after serving 20 years, he returns to Cabot Cove to prove he was wrongly convicted. Swamp Thing is in this episode!

A temporary blackout at a recording studio leaves Jessica in the dark when the wealthy, soon-to-be-owner is stabbed to death.

Season 3, Episode 22: Murder, She Spoke (May 10, 1987)

Jessica has been booked in a studio to record her mystery books as part of a series for the blind. Mid-recording, a blackout hits the studio, and when the lights come back on, someone discovers Randy Whitman, the owner-to-be, dying of a stab wound to the back.

Who’s in it, outside of Angela Lansbury?

William Atherton (Greg Dalton): The undisputed king of the “guy you love to hate.” Before he was getting his house covered in marshmallows in Ghostbusters, he was starring in the 1974 cult classic The Sugarland Express. Seriously, his IMDb is filled with roles that should just say “jerk.”

G.W. Bailey (Lt. Oswald Faraday): Long before he was the bumbling Captain Harris in Police Academy, Bailey was dodging the undead in Tom McLoughlin’s moody 1982 cult horror One Dark Night.

Michael Callan (Carl Anglin): A veteran of the screen who took a dip into the “Nature Gone Wild” subgenre with the 1977 giant-cat-on-the-loose flick The Uncanny, and appeared in the giallo-influenced TV thriller The Killer on Board.

Michael Cole (Earl Tuchman): Best known as Pete from The Mod Squad, but he earned his horror stripes playing the adult Henry Bowers in the original 1990 miniseries adaptation of Stephen King’s It.

Charlie Daniels (Stoney Carmichael): The man who told us the Devil went down to Georgia. While primarily a country legend, his presence here adds that grit necessary for a Southern-fried thriller.

Jonna Lee (Sally Ann Carmichael): A 1980s mainstay who faced off against a supernatural force in the 1984 film Making the Grade.

Fredric Lehne (Al Parker): You recognize him as the “Yellow-Eyed Demon” (Azazel) from Supernatural. He’s a genre veteran who also appeared in Night Game, a slasher set at a baseball stadium.

Wendy Phillips (Nancy Dalton): She survived the 1988 TV movie The People Across the Lake, which is a textbook “suburban nightmare” thriller.

Constance Towers (Margaret Witworth): A genuine icon of cult cinema. She starred in Samuel Fuller’s insane 1963 masterpiece Shock Corridor and the 1964 neo-noir The Naked Kiss. If you haven’t seen them, fix your life.

Patrick Wayne (Randy Witworth): The son of The Duke himself. He led the charge against Ray Harryhausen monsters in the 1977 fantasy-adventure cult classic Sinbad and the Eye of the Tiger.

Mark Neely (Sergeant): A familiar face from The Young and the Restless, Neely also did time in the 1981 slasher Graduation Day.

Trish Garland (Secretary): Mostly known for her stage work, but she popped up in the psychological thriller The 4th Floor.

Austin Kelly (Cabbie): A reliable character actor who appeared in the gritty 1970s crime-cult classic Across 110th Street.

What happens?

If you thought the most dangerous thing in a recording studio was a high-pitched feedback loop or a diva’s rider, you clearly haven’t spent enough time in Cabot Cove’s extended universe.

In this week’s episode, our favorite mystery writer is recording her books for the blind. Naturally, because Jessica can’t even go to the grocery store without someone checking out permanently, a blackout hits the studio. When the lights flicker back on, Randy Whitman—the studio’s owner-to-be and a man with all the charm of a paper cut—is found with a knife in his back.

Enter Lt. Faraday, played by G.W. Bailey, who has apparently decided that since he can’t stop Mahoney and Tackleberry, he’ll spend his time being a condescending misogynist to a world-famous novelist. Faraday immediately pivots his detective skills toward Greg Dalton, the blind producer.

Why Greg? Because Faraday’s logic is airtight: Greg can move in the dark, he was near the switch, and he’s the suspicious type. Meanwhile, Jessica finds a bottle of expensive purple nail polish at the scene. That leads her to:

• Suspect A: Cindy, the runaway niece of country star Stoney Carmichael, wears purple polish, but it’s the cheap stuff.
• Suspect B: The victim’s widow, who seems about as sad as someone who just won the lottery, wears the expensive brand.
• The Reality: The nail polish is a Total Red Herring. It has absolutely nothing to do with the murder, but it gives Jessica something to do while Faraday is busy being useless.

Things get messy when Jessica catches Nancy Dalton (Greg’s wife) trying to hide a set of matching silverware in the dryer. Pro tip: if your husband is a murder suspect, don’t try to tumble-dry the evidence. Jessica has to gently remind her that “Obstruction of Justice” isn’t a great look for the fall season.

The lightbulb — literally, see the trivia — finally goes off for J.B. when Faraday calls her and mistakes her recorded voice for her actual voice. Suddenly, the blackout rehearsals and the constant technical difficulties during Stoney’s recording sessions make sense.

Who did it?

Al Parker. He flipped a master switch on his keyboard to cause the blackouts, using them as dress rehearsals to frame Greg (who was conveniently distracted by his meds at the time).

How did Al pull off the ultimate alibi? The old Recorded Audio Trick. He made it look like Randy was calling him on the phone, but Al was actually just listening to a recording of Randy’s voice. This kept Randy pinned in one spot for the stabbing while making Al look like he was elsewhere, chatting away with the soon-to-be corpse.

Al tries to play it cool, claiming the evidence is circumstantial, which is a classic move for a guy who just got outsmarted by a woman in a smart blazer. It isn’t until Faraday finds the actual alibi tape (thanks to a heavy nudge from Jessica) that Al finally folds.

Faraday ends the episode by graciously admitting he’ll never undervalue female intuition again. Jessica likely responded with a polite smile, while internally calculating exactly how many ways she could have disposed of his body without leaving a trace.

Be nice to Jessica Fletcher. She has a very intimate relationship with death.

Who made it?

This was directed by Jessica’s real-life son, Anthony Pullen Shaw and written by Si Rose, who created Sigmund and the Sea Monster and Dr. Shrinker.

Does Jessica dress up and act stupid? Does she get some?

No. I’m wondering if I’ll ever see that again. Maybe in season 4? This is the last episode of season 3.

Was it any good?

Yes!

Any trivia?

The moment that Jessica figures out who the murderer is, a light bulb comes on above her head.

Screenshot

Give me a reasonable quote:

Lt. Faraday: Oh, I think writing is a real good hobby for a woman. You can cook up some supper. You can chat on the phone. And then pop over to the old typewriter now and then for a few minutes.

Jessica Fletcher: Yes. When I’m not too busy beating laundry against the rocks in the river.

What’s next?

The first episode of season 4! Jessica jaunts to Paris at the behest of an old friend whose fashion boutique is in financial trouble. When a local loan shark is murdered, she must dig deep to find the truth.

This episode is a surrealist take on the Ghost Train story, serving as an allegory for death and the afterlife.

Stacey (Begonya Plaza), a college student traveling home for Thanksgiving, finds herself alone in a desolate train station. The atmosphere is immediately off as the station feels abandoned, and an exit sign falls from the wall without provocation. When her train arrives, she boards the very last car, the caboose.

Inside, she meets three eccentric passengers. Mrs. Crane (Mary Carver) is a grandmotherly figure who knits incessantly and speaks in soothing, rhythmic metaphors. The Old Man (Louis Guss) is a silent, suited passenger focused on his lunch box. And finally, Joe (Scooter Stevens) is a young boy dressed in a cowboy outfit who appears restless.

Mrs. Crane welcomes Stacey, explaining that the last car sways like a cradle. Stacey attempts to relax, but the logic of the world begins to fray. She notices her watch has stopped, and when the train enters its first tunnel, the lights flicker to the sound of a haunting, maniacal laugh. For a fleeting second, Stacey sees her own reflection closing the window shades independently of her movements.

As the journey continues, Stacey realizes she is trapped. The door to the next car is locked, appearing and disappearing, with signs forbidding passage while the train is in motion. Time becomes elastic; Joe inexplicably changes costumes, from a cowboy to an infantry soldier, and the passengers seem to know Stacey’s name despite never being introduced.

The horror escalates during the second tunnel sequence. Joe begins shooting his toy gun, but the play turns lethal. The Old Man is riddled with actual bullet holes and slumps over, dead. Stacey screams in terror, but as soon as the train exits the tunnel, the Old Man sits up, perfectly intact, and begins eating a sandwich as if nothing happened. Mrs. Crane simply smiles and tells a shell-shocked Stacey, “You get used to the tunnels… eventually.”

The appearance of the Conductor (Bert Williams) brings no relief. When Stacey demands to be let off or taken to the dining car, she is met with bureaucratic indifference. She offers her round-trip ticket, but the Conductor clips it and returns a one-way ticket, claiming it is the only kind he has.

Stacey’s desperation peaks when she looks through the door’s window as the Conductor leaves. For a split second, the polished interior of the train vanishes, replaced by a rotting, skeletal wreckage. The passengers are revealed as decayed corpses, and the Conductor is a grinning skeleton. However, as the train emerges into the light, the illusion of normalcy returns.

Mrs. Crane reveals the true nature of their journey: the Conductor won’t return until there is a new passenger to collect. Stacey is no longer a traveler; she is now a permanent fixture of the last car. Mrs. Crane drapes a handmade shawl around Stacey’s shoulders—the very one she had been knitting since Stacey boarded—and offers to teach her how to knit. This is the acceptance of death.

The episode concludes with the train entering another tunnel. This time, Stacey doesn’t scream. Instead, she joins the others in a rhythmic, catatonic chant: “Tunnel… Tunnel… Tunnel.” As the darkness engulfs the car, Stacey’s face withers into a pale, skeletal mask. She has finally gotten used to the tunnels, becoming just another ghost on a train that never reaches its destination.

This episode was directed by John Strysik, who directed five other episodes of this series. It was written by Michael McDowell, who wrote the script for Beetlejuice. This is one of the strongest episodes of the show.

Jessica investigates the possibility that a man spent 30 years in prison for a murder he did not commit.

Season 3, Episode 21: The Days Dwindle Down (April 19, 1987)

An elderly waitress begs for J.B.’s help in solving a decades-old murder.

Who’s in it, outside of Angela Lansbury?

Richard Beymer (Sydney Jarvis): Best known as Tony in the original West Side Story, cult cinema fans adore him as Ben Horne in Twin Peaks. Here, he plays the man on trial for his life, providing the episode’s central tension.

June Havoc (Thelma Vantay): A true vaudeville legend (and the real-life sister of Gypsy Rose Lee), she brings old-school theatrical gravity to the role of the domineering mother-in-law.

Harry Morgan (Retired Lt. Richard Webb): Before he was Colonel Potter on M’A’S’H, he was Jack Webb’s partner on Dragnet. In a fun meta twist, he plays a retired detective whom Jessica hires to help her dig into the case.

Susan Strasberg (Dorothy Hearn Davis): The daughter of legendary acting coach Lee Strasberg, Susan was a “Method” darling who appeared in everything from Picnic to the psychedelic cult classic The Trip. She plays the tragic wife whose death sets the plot in motion.

Gloria Stuart (Edna Jarvis): Decades before she became a household name (and Oscar nominee) as “Old Rose” in James Cameron’s Titanic, Stuart was a 1930s starlet. She appears here in the present day, while Katherine Emery appears in uncredited archive footage as a younger version of her.

Art Hindle (Rod Wilson): A Canadian legend! If you love 70s/80s horror, you know him from David Cronenberg’s The Brood and the 1978 Invasion of the Body Snatchers. He plays the Wilson family’s son.

Martha Scott (Georgia Wilson): An Academy Award nominee for Our Town, she’s perhaps most famous for playing Charlton Heston’s mother in both The Ten Commandments and Ben-Hur. She plays the Wilson matriarch.

Jeffrey Lynn (Sam Wilson): A former leading man from the 1940s (Four Daughters), he returned to the screen for this role after a period of semi-retirement.

Debbie Zipp (Terry Wilson): A Murder, She Wrote regular. She appeared in several episodes playing different characters, most notably as the wife of Jessica’s nephew, Grady Fletcher.

Tom Dreesen (Peabody): A legendary stand-up comedian who famously toured with Frank Sinatra for years. He steps into a character role here.

Emory Bass (Manager): A character actor staple who you might recognize from 1776 or his numerous appearances on The Love Boat.

Russ Marin (Lt. Sharp): A “that guy” actor seen in everything from The Rockford Files to Buck Rogers in the 25th Century.

Mark Pilon (Male Secretary): A prolific voice actor and performer who appeared in various 80s staples like Knots Landing.

Walter Smith (Restaurant Patron): One of the unsung heroes of Hollywood—a professional background actor who appeared in hundreds of episodes of television, including over 40 episodes of Murder, She Wrote alone!

What happens?

Jessica is living the high life in a luxury hotel suite—probably on the dime of her publisher or some poor sap who didn’t realize inviting J.B. Fletcher to your city is a death warrant for at least one local socialite.

While she’s being pampered, she’s approached by Georgia Wilson. Georgia’s husband, Sam, just got out of the slammer after serving thirty years. He was sent up for the rub-out of his boss, Richard Jarvis. Sam’s story? He was framed. He claims Jarvis’s firm went bust, and the guy offered Sam his last ten grand to make his suicide look like an armed robbery so the insurance company would cough up a fortune for the Jarvis family. Only problem? Someone actually did kill him before the plan went south.

Sam and Georgia’s son, Rod, became a cop specifically to clear his old man’s name. He puts his badge and his expertise at Jessica’s disposal. Along with a retired Lt. Webb, they start digging into 30-year-old forensic evidence.

Naturally, someone isn’t happy about this walk down memory lane. After someone takes a literal shot at Jessica with a matching bullet, J.B. realizes the past isn’t dead.

Who did it?

The victim died by accident. His wife arrived home, caught him mid-attempt and tried to snatch the heater out of his hand because she actually loved the guy. Bang! The gun goes off in the struggle. The big giveaway for J.B. Webb? The fingerprints on the barrel proved it was a wrestling match, not a solo act.

Who made it?

This was directed by Michael J. Lynch and written by Philip Gerson.

Does Jessica dress up and act stupid? Does she get some?

No. I’m wondering if I’ll ever see that.

Was it any good?

Yes, as always.

Any trivia?

The flashbacks are taken from the film Strange Bargain. Jeffrey Lynn, Martha Scott and Harry Morgan reprise their roles from the movie. In the movie, Lt. Webb identifies the murderer, and Sam is saved from prison.

Richard Beymer, who played Sydney Jarvis, was actually 14 years younger than Raymond Roe, who played the same character in Strange Behavior. By this point, he’d retired and was a Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Deputy.

Give me a reasonable quote:

Retired Lt. Richard Webb: I figured she was playin’ bedsheet bingo with the boss.

What’s next?

A temporary blackout at a recording studio leaves Jessica in the dark when the wealthy, soon-to-be-owner is stabbed to death.

The reform mayor dies in a so-called “accident,” and the mayor’s father is murdered after he demands an investigation into it.

Season 3, Episode 20: The Cemetery Vote (April 5, 1987)

Jessica investigates when her nephew, a junior executive for a large accounting firm, is charged with tax fraud and the murder of his boss.

Who’s in it, outside of Angela Lansbury?

Bruce Davison plays David Carroll, and the man is a legend, appearing in Willard, The Lords of Salem, and so many more movies.

Ed Lauter is the law here; Sheriff Orville Yates and no one played the menacing authority figure better. He was the creepy attendant in Cujo, the cop dealing with Bronson in Death Wish 3 and fought off The Car.

Marie Windsor is Kate Gunnerson, and she was in The Day Mars Invaded Earth.

Jeff Yagher plays Deputy Wayne Beeler. He was in V.

Joseph Campanella is George McDaniels.

Charlene Tilton plays Cyndy March and is best known for Dallas.

Mitchell Ryan is Captain Ernest Lenko, and I will always know him for his role in Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers as Dr. Terence Wynn, the man behind the Cult of Thorn.

Ellen Bry plays Linda Stevens, John McLiam is Harry Stevens, Dick Balduzzi plays Gil Stokes, Katherine De Hetre is Rita, Zale Kessler plays the coroner, Neal Penso is a paramedic and Hank Robinson and Ilona Wilson are casino players.

What happens?

Look, we all know J.B. Fletcher has more dear old friends than a politician has skeletons in the closet, like the Angel of Death. This time, she’s trekking out to Comstock, Idaho. It’s another one of those fictional map-dots that seem to exist only so someone can get murdered in it.

Our girl Jess is living her best life in Rome when she rings up Seth Hazlitt and gets the skinny: Linda Stevens (who we assume is a Cabot Cove expat because they once shared a picnic on the beach) is now a widow. Her husband, the Mayor, took a permanent detour in a car crash. Jess does what Jess does. She cuts the pasta tour short and flies into the eye of the storm to comfort the grieving friend. But Linda’s father-in-law, Harry, isn’t buying the accident narrative. He thinks the town’s political machine is running on high-octane foul play.

So he dies too. Turns out, being the only guy in town asking the right questions is a great way to get a one-way ticket to the morgue.

Who did it?

Deputy Mayor David Carroll! Bruce Davison goes from clean-up candidate to clean the blood off the carpet real fast. Carroll was playing both sides of the fence, tipping off an illegal gambling ring about police raids. Why? Because he wanted their political support (read: dirty money and influence) to slide into the Mayor’s chair.

Who made it?

This was directed by Seymour Robbie and written by Robert Van Scoyk.

Does Jessica dress up and act stupid? Does she get some?

No. A serious and non-sexy J.B. Boo.

Was it any good?

It’s decent.

Any trivia?

The sound of the truck that runs Jessica and David off the road was taken from the made-for-TV movie Duel.

Give me a reasonable quote:

Jessica Fletcher: Well, I really have to get home. Amos Tupper may uphold the law, but I can’t trust him to water my plants.

What’s next?

Jessica investigates the possibility that a man spent 30 years in prison for a murder he did not commit. Art Hindle is in this episode!