If you ever wondered what happens when the theater world’s hyper-progressive cancel culture collides head-on with MAGA counter-culture in the middle of the Georgia woods, American Theater is the answer. Directed by Nicholas Clark and Dylan Frederick, this 2025 Slamdance Grand Jury Prize winner plays out like a real-world, bizarro-universe Waiting for Guffman.
The film is a fly-on-the-wall documentary following Brian Clowdus, a real-life, openly gay conservative director who once possessed a massive regional reputation for staging over-the-top, immersive outdoor musicals. After being heavily ousted from the mainstream Atlanta theater circuit in 2020 following a flood of accusations regarding toxic leadership, unsafe sets and bigotry, Clowdus doesn’t apologize. He rebrands.
He retreats to an isolated, weathered cabin in rural Georgia and rounds up a dedicated troupe of right-leaning, conservative actors. His grand scheme for artistic vengeance? Staging an original, allegorical, fiercely political musical retelling of the 1692 Salem witch trials, casting himself and his cast as the true victims of a modern-day ideological witch hunt. As if the rehearsals aren’t high-stakes enough, the cameras capture Clowdus simultaneously running a chaotic, real-world campaign for the Florida House of Representatives.
Because this is a slice-of-life verité documentary rather than a scripted production, the actors are real-life historical figures from this specific theater subculture. I couldn’t believe this was real, but there you go. This article — thanks for sharing, Alexei Toliopoulos — goes quite deep into just how wild the star of this movie is.
Clowdus is the larger-than-life center of gravity around which this movie spirals. Sporting a thick Southern drawl and endless energy, he treats his rehearsals like military operations and religious revivals rolled into one. He fills the screen with the kind of intense, unedited eccentric charisma usually reserved for cult leaders or grindhouse exploitation villains as he leads a collection of conservative-leaning actors who feel completely alienated by the mainstream arts community. The documentary captures them oscillating between intense vulnerability, fierce ideological conviction and genuine panic as they are subjected to Clowdus’s trademark dangerous theatrical choices. These include frighteningly close pyrotechnics, unpadded physical stunts and increasingly unhinged staging demands.
Directors Clark and Frederick use no talking-head interviews or voiceovers to guide your opinion. The camera just sits in the corner of the cabin and lets the madness unfold naturally, all in a literal cabin in the woods, as unsafe stage combat missed cues and show tunes tell the tale. And when the show gets canceled, everyone gets drunk and decides to test out being lynched, well… seriously, this was a real thing, not a script?
Watching this virtually at the Chattanooga Film Festival, I wished I had seen it live with an audience, because it’s one of the most uncomfortable movies I’ve seen. It goes from being funny at times to being frankly terrifying, as we’ve all built such walls around ourselves and have chosen such strange bedfellows in these most horrible of times.
What a movie.

You can watch this either in-person or virtually at the Chattanooga Film Festival. For more info, visit the official site.


You must be logged in to post a comment.